lgb.cv.R 19.2 KB
Newer Older
James Lamb's avatar
James Lamb committed
1
2
#' @importFrom R6 R6Class
CVBooster <- R6::R6Class(
3
  classname = "lgb.CVBooster",
4
  cloneable = FALSE,
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
5
  public = list(
6
    best_iter = -1L,
7
    best_score = NA,
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
8
    record_evals = list(),
9
10
    boosters = list(),
    initialize = function(x) {
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
11
      self$boosters <- x
12
      return(invisible(NULL))
13
    },
14
    reset_parameter = function(new_params) {
15
16
17
      for (x in boosters) {
        x$reset_parameter(params = new_params)
      }
18
      return(invisible(self))
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
19
20
21
22
    }
  )
)

23
#' @name lgb.cv
James Lamb's avatar
James Lamb committed
24
#' @title Main CV logic for LightGBM
James Lamb's avatar
James Lamb committed
25
26
#' @description Cross validation logic used by LightGBM
#' @inheritParams lgb_shared_params
27
#' @param nfold the original dataset is randomly partitioned into \code{nfold} equal size subsamples.
28
#' @param label Vector of labels, used if \code{data} is not an \code{\link{lgb.Dataset}}
29
#' @param weight vector of response values. If not NULL, will set to dataset
30
#' @param record Boolean, TRUE will record iteration message to \code{booster$record_evals}
31
32
33
#' @param showsd \code{boolean}, whether to show standard deviation of cross validation.
#'               This parameter defaults to \code{TRUE}. Setting it to \code{FALSE} can lead to a
#'               slight speedup by avoiding unnecessary computation.
34
#' @param stratified a \code{boolean} indicating whether sampling of folds should be stratified
35
#'                   by the values of outcome labels.
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
36
#' @param folds \code{list} provides a possibility to use a list of pre-defined CV folds
37
38
#'              (each element must be a vector of test fold's indices). When folds are supplied,
#'              the \code{nfold} and \code{stratified} parameters are ignored.
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
39
#' @param colnames feature names, if not null, will use this to overwrite the names in dataset
40
41
42
#' @param categorical_feature categorical features. This can either be a character vector of feature
#'                            names or an integer vector with the indices of the features (e.g.
#'                            \code{c(1L, 10L)} to say "the first and tenth columns").
43
44
45
#' @param callbacks List of callback functions that are applied at each iteration.
#' @param reset_data Boolean, setting it to TRUE (not the default value) will transform the booster model
#'                   into a predictor model which frees up memory and the original datasets
46
#' @inheritSection lgb_shared_params Early Stopping
47
#' @return a trained model \code{lgb.CVBooster}.
48
#'
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
49
#' @examples
50
#' \donttest{
51
52
53
#' data(agaricus.train, package = "lightgbm")
#' train <- agaricus.train
#' dtrain <- lgb.Dataset(train$data, label = train$label)
54
55
56
57
58
59
#' params <- list(
#'   objective = "regression"
#'   , metric = "l2"
#'   , min_data = 1L
#'   , learning_rate = 1.0
#' )
60
61
62
#' model <- lgb.cv(
#'   params = params
#'   , data = dtrain
63
#'   , nrounds = 5L
64
#'   , nfold = 3L
65
#' )
66
#' }
67
#' @importFrom data.table data.table setorderv
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
68
#' @export
69
70
lgb.cv <- function(params = list()
                   , data
71
                   , nrounds = 100L
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
                   , nfold = 3L
                   , label = NULL
                   , weight = NULL
                   , obj = NULL
                   , eval = NULL
                   , verbose = 1L
                   , record = TRUE
                   , eval_freq = 1L
80
                   , showsd = TRUE
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
                   , stratified = TRUE
                   , folds = NULL
                   , init_model = NULL
                   , colnames = NULL
                   , categorical_feature = NULL
                   , early_stopping_rounds = NULL
                   , callbacks = list()
                   , reset_data = FALSE
89
                   , serializable = TRUE
90
                   ) {
91

92
93
94
95
96
  if (nrounds <= 0L) {
    stop("nrounds should be greater than zero")
  }

  # If 'data' is not an lgb.Dataset, try to construct one using 'label'
97
  if (!lgb.is.Dataset(x = data)) {
98
99
100
    if (is.null(label)) {
      stop("'label' must be provided for lgb.cv if 'data' is not an 'lgb.Dataset'")
    }
101
    data <- lgb.Dataset(data = data, label = label)
102
103
  }

104
105
  # Setup temporary variables
  params$verbose <- verbose
106
107
  params <- lgb.check.obj(params = params, obj = obj)
  params <- lgb.check.eval(params = params, eval = eval)
108
  fobj <- NULL
109
  eval_functions <- list(NULL)
110

111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
  # set some parameters, resolving the way they were passed in with other parameters
  # in `params`.
  # this ensures that the model stored with Booster$save() correctly represents
  # what was passed in
  params <- lgb.check.wrapper_param(
    main_param_name = "num_iterations"
    , params = params
    , alternative_kwarg_value = nrounds
  )
  params <- lgb.check.wrapper_param(
    main_param_name = "early_stopping_round"
    , params = params
    , alternative_kwarg_value = early_stopping_rounds
  )
  early_stopping_rounds <- params[["early_stopping_round"]]

127
  # Check for objective (function or not)
128
  if (is.function(params$objective)) {
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
129
130
131
    fobj <- params$objective
    params$objective <- "NONE"
  }
132

133
  # If eval is a single function, store it as a 1-element list
134
  # (for backwards compatibility). If it is a list of functions, store
135
136
  # all of them. This makes it possible to pass any mix of strings like "auc"
  # and custom functions to eval
137
  if (is.function(eval)) {
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
    eval_functions <- list(eval)
  }
  if (methods::is(eval, "list")) {
    eval_functions <- Filter(
      f = is.function
      , x = eval
    )
145
  }
146

147
  # Init predictor to empty
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
148
  predictor <- NULL
149

150
  # Check for boosting from a trained model
151
  if (is.character(init_model)) {
152
153
    predictor <- Predictor$new(modelfile = init_model)
  } else if (lgb.is.Booster(x = init_model)) {
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
154
155
    predictor <- init_model$to_predictor()
  }
156

157
  # Set the iteration to start from / end to (and check for boosting from a trained model, again)
158
  begin_iteration <- 1L
159
  if (!is.null(predictor)) {
160
    begin_iteration <- predictor$current_iter() + 1L
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
161
  }
162
  end_iteration <- begin_iteration + params[["num_iterations"]] - 1L
163

164
165
166
167
168
  # pop interaction_constraints off of params. It needs some preprocessing on the
  # R side before being passed into the Dataset object
  interaction_constraints <- params[["interaction_constraints"]]
  params["interaction_constraints"] <- NULL

169
170
171
172
  # Construct datasets, if needed
  data$update_params(params = params)
  data$construct()

173
174
175
176
177
178
179
  # Check interaction constraints
  cnames <- NULL
  if (!is.null(colnames)) {
    cnames <- colnames
  } else if (!is.null(data$get_colnames())) {
    cnames <- data$get_colnames()
  }
180
181
182
183
  params[["interaction_constraints"]] <- lgb.check_interaction_constraints(
    interaction_constraints = interaction_constraints
    , column_names = cnames
  )
184

185
  if (!is.null(weight)) {
186
    data$set_field(field_name = "weight", data = weight)
187
  }
188

189
  # Update parameters with parsed parameters
190
  data$update_params(params = params)
191

192
  # Create the predictor set
193
  data$.__enclos_env__$private$set_predictor(predictor = predictor)
194

195
196
  # Write column names
  if (!is.null(colnames)) {
197
    data$set_colnames(colnames = colnames)
198
  }
199

200
201
  # Write categorical features
  if (!is.null(categorical_feature)) {
202
    data$set_categorical_feature(categorical_feature = categorical_feature)
203
  }
204

205
  if (!is.null(folds)) {
206

207
    # Check for list of folds or for single value
208
    if (!identical(class(folds), "list") || length(folds) < 2L) {
209
      stop(sQuote("folds"), " must be a list with 2 or more elements that are vectors of indices for each CV-fold")
210
    }
211

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
212
    nfold <- length(folds)
213

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
214
  } else {
215

216
    if (nfold <= 1L) {
217
218
      stop(sQuote("nfold"), " must be > 1")
    }
219

220
    # Create folds
221
    folds <- generate.cv.folds(
222
223
224
      nfold = nfold
      , nrows = nrow(data)
      , stratified = stratified
225
226
      , label = get_field(dataset = data, field_name = "label")
      , group = get_field(dataset = data, field_name = "group")
227
      , params = params
228
    )
229

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
230
  }
231

232
  # Add printing log callback
233
  if (verbose > 0L && eval_freq > 0L) {
234
    callbacks <- add.cb(cb_list = callbacks, cb = cb.print.evaluation(period = eval_freq))
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
235
  }
236

237
238
  # Add evaluation log callback
  if (record) {
239
    callbacks <- add.cb(cb_list = callbacks, cb = cb.record.evaluation())
240
  }
241

242
  # Did user pass parameters that indicate they want to use early stopping?
243
  using_early_stopping <- !is.null(early_stopping_rounds) && early_stopping_rounds > 0L
244
245
246
247
248

  boosting_param_names <- .PARAMETER_ALIASES()[["boosting"]]
  using_dart <- any(
    sapply(
      X = boosting_param_names
249
250
      , FUN = function(param) {
        identical(params[[param]], "dart")
251
      }
252
253
254
255
    )
  )

  # Cannot use early stopping with 'dart' boosting
256
  if (using_dart) {
257
    warning("Early stopping is not available in 'dart' mode.")
258
    using_early_stopping <- FALSE
259
260
261

    # Remove the cb.early.stop() function if it was passed in to callbacks
    callbacks <- Filter(
262
      f = function(cb_func) {
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
        !identical(attr(cb_func, "name"), "cb.early.stop")
      }
      , x = callbacks
    )
  }

  # If user supplied early_stopping_rounds, add the early stopping callback
270
  if (using_early_stopping) {
271
    callbacks <- add.cb(
272
273
      cb_list = callbacks
      , cb = cb.early.stop(
274
        stopping_rounds = early_stopping_rounds
275
        , first_metric_only = isTRUE(params[["first_metric_only"]])
276
277
278
        , verbose = verbose
      )
    )
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
279
  }
280

281
  cb <- categorize.callbacks(cb_list = callbacks)
282

283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
  # Construct booster for each fold. The data.table() code below is used to
  # guarantee that indices are sorted while keeping init_score and weight together
  # with the correct indices. Note that it takes advantage of the fact that
  # someDT$some_column returns NULL is 'some_column' does not exist in the data.table
  bst_folds <- lapply(
    X = seq_along(folds)
    , FUN = function(k) {

      # For learning-to-rank, each fold is a named list with two elements:
      #   * `fold` = an integer vector of row indices
      #   * `group` = an integer vector describing which groups are in the fold
      # For classification or regression tasks, it will just be an integer
      # vector of row indices
      folds_have_group <- "group" %in% names(folds[[k]])
      if (folds_have_group) {
        test_indices <- folds[[k]]$fold
        test_group_indices <- folds[[k]]$group
300
301
        test_groups <- get_field(dataset = data, field_name = "group")[test_group_indices]
        train_groups <- get_field(dataset = data, field_name = "group")[-test_group_indices]
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
      } else {
        test_indices <- folds[[k]]
      }
      train_indices <- seq_len(nrow(data))[-test_indices]

      # set up test set
      indexDT <- data.table::data.table(
        indices = test_indices
310
311
        , weight = get_field(dataset = data, field_name = "weight")[test_indices]
        , init_score = get_field(dataset = data, field_name = "init_score")[test_indices]
312
      )
313
      data.table::setorderv(x = indexDT, cols = "indices", order = 1L)
314
      dtest <- slice(data, indexDT$indices)
315
316
      set_field(dataset = dtest, field_name = "weight", data = indexDT$weight)
      set_field(dataset = dtest, field_name = "init_score", data = indexDT$init_score)
317
318
319
320

      # set up training set
      indexDT <- data.table::data.table(
        indices = train_indices
321
322
        , weight = get_field(dataset = data, field_name = "weight")[train_indices]
        , init_score = get_field(dataset = data, field_name = "init_score")[train_indices]
323
      )
324
      data.table::setorderv(x = indexDT, cols = "indices", order = 1L)
325
      dtrain <- slice(data, indexDT$indices)
326
327
      set_field(dataset = dtrain, field_name = "weight", data = indexDT$weight)
      set_field(dataset = dtrain, field_name = "init_score", data = indexDT$init_score)
328
329

      if (folds_have_group) {
330
331
        set_field(dataset = dtest, field_name = "group", data = test_groups)
        set_field(dataset = dtrain, field_name = "group", data = train_groups)
332
333
      }

334
335
      booster <- Booster$new(params = params, train_set = dtrain)
      booster$add_valid(data = dtest, name = "valid")
336
337
338
339
340
      return(
        list(booster = booster)
      )
    }
  )
341

342
  # Create new booster
343
  cv_booster <- CVBooster$new(x = bst_folds)
344

345
346
347
  # Callback env
  env <- CB_ENV$new()
  env$model <- cv_booster
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
348
  env$begin_iteration <- begin_iteration
349
  env$end_iteration <- end_iteration
350

351
  # Start training model using number of iterations to start and end with
352
  for (i in seq.int(from = begin_iteration, to = end_iteration)) {
353

354
    # Overwrite iteration in environment
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
355
356
    env$iteration <- i
    env$eval_list <- list()
357

358
359
360
    for (f in cb$pre_iter) {
      f(env)
    }
361

362
    # Update one boosting iteration
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
363
    msg <- lapply(cv_booster$boosters, function(fd) {
364
      fd$booster$update(fobj = fobj)
365
366
367
368
369
      out <- list()
      for (eval_function in eval_functions) {
        out <- append(out, fd$booster$eval_valid(feval = eval_function))
      }
      return(out)
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
370
    })
371

372
    # Prepare collection of evaluation results
373
374
375
376
    merged_msg <- lgb.merge.cv.result(
      msg = msg
      , showsd = showsd
    )
377

378
    # Write evaluation result in environment
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
379
    env$eval_list <- merged_msg$eval_list
380

381
    # Check for standard deviation requirement
382
    if (showsd) {
383
384
      env$eval_err_list <- merged_msg$eval_err_list
    }
385

386
387
388
389
    # Loop through env
    for (f in cb$post_iter) {
      f(env)
    }
390

391
    # Check for early stopping and break if needed
392
    if (env$met_early_stop) break
393

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
394
  }
395

396
397
  # When early stopping is not activated, we compute the best iteration / score ourselves
  # based on the first first metric
398
  if (record && is.na(env$best_score)) {
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
    # when using a custom eval function, the metric name is returned from the
    # function, so figure it out from record_evals
    if (!is.null(eval_functions[1L])) {
      first_metric <- names(cv_booster$record_evals[["valid"]])[1L]
    } else {
      first_metric <- cv_booster$.__enclos_env__$private$eval_names[1L]
    }
406
407
408
    .find_best <- which.min
    if (isTRUE(env$eval_list[[1L]]$higher_better[1L])) {
      .find_best <- which.max
409
    }
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
    cv_booster$best_iter <- unname(
      .find_best(
        unlist(
          cv_booster$record_evals[["valid"]][[first_metric]][[.EVAL_KEY()]]
        )
      )
    )
    cv_booster$best_score <- cv_booster$record_evals[["valid"]][[first_metric]][[.EVAL_KEY()]][[cv_booster$best_iter]]
418
  }
419

420
421
422
  if (reset_data) {
    lapply(cv_booster$boosters, function(fd) {
      # Store temporarily model data elsewhere
423
424
      booster_old <- list(
        best_iter = fd$booster$best_iter
425
        , best_score = fd$booster$best_score
426
427
        , record_evals = fd$booster$record_evals
      )
428
429
430
431
432
433
434
      # Reload model
      fd$booster <- lgb.load(model_str = fd$booster$save_model_to_string())
      fd$booster$best_iter <- booster_old$best_iter
      fd$booster$best_score <- booster_old$best_score
      fd$booster$record_evals <- booster_old$record_evals
    })
  }
435

436
437
438
439
  if (serializable) {
    lapply(cv_booster$boosters, function(model) model$booster$save_raw())
  }

440
  return(cv_booster)
441

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
442
443
444
}

# Generates random (stratified if needed) CV folds
445
generate.cv.folds <- function(nfold, nrows, stratified, label, group, params) {
446

447
448
  # Check for group existence
  if (is.null(group)) {
449

450
    # Shuffle
451
    rnd_idx <- sample.int(nrows)
452

453
    # Request stratified folds
454
    if (isTRUE(stratified) && params$objective %in% c("binary", "multiclass") && length(label) == length(rnd_idx)) {
455

456
      y <- label[rnd_idx]
457
      y <- as.factor(y)
458
      folds <- lgb.stratified.folds(y = y, k = nfold)
459

460
    } else {
461

462
463
      # Make simple non-stratified folds
      folds <- list()
464

465
      # Loop through each fold
466
      for (i in seq_len(nfold)) {
467
        kstep <- length(rnd_idx) %/% (nfold - i + 1L)
468
        folds[[i]] <- rnd_idx[seq_len(kstep)]
469
        rnd_idx <- rnd_idx[-seq_len(kstep)]
470
      }
471

472
    }
473

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
474
  } else {
475

476
477
    # When doing group, stratified is not possible (only random selection)
    if (nfold > length(group)) {
478
      stop("\nYou requested too many folds for the number of available groups.\n")
479
    }
480

481
    # Degroup the groups
482
    ungrouped <- inverse.rle(list(lengths = group, values = seq_along(group)))
483

484
    # Can't stratify, shuffle
485
    rnd_idx <- sample.int(length(group))
486

487
    # Make simple non-stratified folds
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
488
    folds <- list()
489

490
    # Loop through each fold
491
    for (i in seq_len(nfold)) {
492
      kstep <- length(rnd_idx) %/% (nfold - i + 1L)
493
494
495
496
      folds[[i]] <- list(
        fold = which(ungrouped %in% rnd_idx[seq_len(kstep)])
        , group = rnd_idx[seq_len(kstep)]
      )
497
      rnd_idx <- rnd_idx[-seq_len(kstep)]
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
498
    }
499

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
500
  }
501

502
  return(folds)
503

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
504
505
506
}

# Creates CV folds stratified by the values of y.
507
# It was borrowed from caret::createFolds and simplified
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
508
# by always returning an unnamed list of fold indices.
509
#' @importFrom stats quantile
510
lgb.stratified.folds <- function(y, k) {
511

512
513
514
515
516
517
518
519
  ## Group the numeric data based on their magnitudes
  ## and sample within those groups.
  ## When the number of samples is low, we may have
  ## issues further slicing the numeric data into
  ## groups. The number of groups will depend on the
  ## ratio of the number of folds to the sample size.
  ## At most, we will use quantiles. If the sample
  ## is too small, we just do regular unstratified CV
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
520
  if (is.numeric(y)) {
521

522
    cuts <- length(y) %/% k
523
524
    if (cuts < 2L) {
      cuts <- 2L
525
    }
526
527
    if (cuts > 5L) {
      cuts <- 5L
528
529
530
    }
    y <- cut(
      y
531
      , unique(stats::quantile(y, probs = seq.int(0.0, 1.0, length.out = cuts)))
532
533
      , include.lowest = TRUE
    )
534

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
535
  }
536

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
537
  if (k < length(y)) {
538

539
    ## Reset levels so that the possible levels and
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
540
    ## the levels in the vector are the same
541
    y <- as.factor(as.character(y))
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
542
543
    numInClass <- table(y)
    foldVector <- vector(mode = "integer", length(y))
544

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
545
546
547
    ## For each class, balance the fold allocation as far
    ## as possible, then resample the remainder.
    ## The final assignment of folds is also randomized.
548

549
    for (i in seq_along(numInClass)) {
550

551
      ## Create a vector of integers from 1:k as many times as possible without
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
552
553
      ## going over the number of samples in the class. Note that if the number
      ## of samples in a class is less than k, nothing is producd here.
554
      seqVector <- rep(seq_len(k), numInClass[i] %/% k)
555

556
      ## Add enough random integers to get length(seqVector) == numInClass[i]
557
      if (numInClass[i] %% k > 0L) {
558
        seqVector <- c(seqVector, sample.int(k, numInClass[i] %% k))
559
      }
560

561
      ## Shuffle the integers for fold assignment and assign to this classes's data
562
      foldVector[y == dimnames(numInClass)$y[i]] <- sample(seqVector)
563

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
564
    }
565

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
566
  } else {
567

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
568
    foldVector <- seq(along = y)
569

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
570
  }
571

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
572
  out <- split(seq(along = y), foldVector)
573
  names(out) <- NULL
574
  return(out)
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
575
576
}

577
lgb.merge.cv.result <- function(msg, showsd) {
578

579
  if (length(msg) == 0L) {
580
581
    stop("lgb.cv: size of cv result error")
  }
582

583
  eval_len <- length(msg[[1L]])
584

585
  if (eval_len == 0L) {
586
587
    stop("lgb.cv: should provide at least one metric for CV")
  }
588

589
  # Get evaluation results using a list apply
590
  eval_result <- lapply(seq_len(eval_len), function(j) {
591
592
    as.numeric(lapply(seq_along(msg), function(i) {
      msg[[i]][[j]]$value }))
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
593
  })
594

595
  # Get evaluation. Just taking the first element here to
596
  # get structure (name, higher_better, data_name)
597
  ret_eval <- msg[[1L]]
598

599
600
601
  for (j in seq_len(eval_len)) {
    ret_eval[[j]]$value <- mean(eval_result[[j]])
  }
602

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
603
  ret_eval_err <- NULL
604

605
  # Check for standard deviation
606
  if (showsd) {
607

608
    # Parse standard deviation
609
    for (j in seq_len(eval_len)) {
610
611
      ret_eval_err <- c(
        ret_eval_err
612
        , sqrt(mean(eval_result[[j]] ^ 2L) - mean(eval_result[[j]]) ^ 2L)
613
      )
Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
614
    }
615

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
616
    ret_eval_err <- as.list(ret_eval_err)
617

Guolin Ke's avatar
Guolin Ke committed
618
  }
619

620
621
622
623
624
  return(
    list(
      eval_list = ret_eval
      , eval_err_list = ret_eval_err
    )
625
  )
626

627
}