# Refine Plan QA

## Summary

<Brief overview of the refinement process: how many comments were processed, what types of changes were made, and the overall outcome>

## Comment Ledger

<Table tracking all extracted comments with their metadata and disposition>

| CMT-ID | Classification | Location | Original Text (excerpt) | Disposition |
|--------|----------------|----------|-------------------------|-------------|
| CMT-1 | question | AC-2 | "Why do we need..." | Answered in QA, light plan clarification added |
| CMT-2 | change_request | Task Breakdown | "Delete task 5..." | Applied to plan, cross-references updated |
| CMT-3 | research_request | Dependencies | "Investigate config..." | Research completed, findings integrated |

<Disposition values: "answered", "applied", "researched", "deferred", "resolved">

## Answers

<Responses to question-type comments>

### CMT-1: <Question summary>

**Original Comment:**
```
<Full original comment text>
```

**Answer:**
<Detailed explanation addressing the question>

**Plan Changes:**
<Description of any light edits made to clarify the plan, or "None" if only answered in QA>

---

## Research Findings

<Results from research_request-type comments>

### CMT-3: <Research topic summary>

**Original Comment:**
```
<Full original comment text>
```

**Research Scope:**
<What was investigated: files examined, patterns analyzed, existing implementations reviewed>

**Findings:**
<Key discoveries and their implications for the plan>

**Impact on Plan:**
<How the research findings were integrated into the refined plan, or why they were deferred>

---

## Plan Changes Applied

<Documentation of all modifications made to the plan from change_request-type comments>

### CMT-2: <Change summary>

**Original Comment:**
```
<Full original comment text>
```

**Changes Made:**
<Detailed description of what was modified in the plan>

**Affected Sections:**
<List of plan sections that were updated to maintain consistency>
- Acceptance Criteria: <specific changes>
- Task Breakdown: <specific changes>
- Dependencies and Sequence: <specific changes>
- Other: <specific changes>

**Cross-Reference Updates:**
<Any AC-X, task ID, or milestone references that were updated to maintain consistency>

---

## Remaining Decisions

<Unresolved items that require user input or further clarification>

### DEC-X: <Decision topic>

**Related Comments:** CMT-4, CMT-7

**Context:**
<Background and why this decision is needed>

**Options:**
1. <Option A>: <description, tradeoffs>
2. <Option B>: <description, tradeoffs>

**Recommendation:**
<Suggested approach with rationale, or "No clear recommendation" if options are equally viable>

**Status:** PENDING

---

## Refinement Metadata

- **Input Plan:** <path/to/input-plan.md>
- **Output Plan:** <path/to/refined-plan.md>
- **QA Document:** <path/to/qa-document.md>
- **Total Comments Processed:** <count>
  - Questions: <count>
  - Change Requests: <count>
  - Research Requests: <count>
- **Plan Sections Modified:** <list of sections>
- **Convergence Status:** <converged | partially_converged>
- **Refinement Date:** <YYYY-MM-DD>
